After a 4 1/2 hour journey I arrived in rainy Torquay (“The English Riviera” or, as some locals more appropriately call it, “The English River Area”), venue for the second year running of the Naace Conference. Having enjoyed last year’s conference I have been looking forward to this one. So will it live up to expectations…?
After settling into the hotel (The Livermead House) and having a very pleasant meal, it was off to the Riviera Centre for the initial keynote speeches of the conference.
ICT Challenges and Expectations
This was the opening address from Jim Knight, Minister of State for Schools and 14 – 19 Learners. The session was a videoconference, as Jim was clearly too busy to leave London and travel to Torquay to be with us in person.
In the speech he commented on the postcode lottery of education and that, for example, there were 25 percentage points between 5 A* – C GCSEs in Bristol & Buckinghamshire (Buckinghamshire being the higher, of course – let’s hope that the county council remember this fact during the School Improvement Service Review!)
He stated that it is “…essential we use technology in schools because it makes a difference not because we can” and went on to talk about personalised learning. He spoke about technology reaching out to parents (but what about those who can’t afford the technology?) and commented that VLEs save teachers time – half an hour a day (but how exactly? How was this measured?) He also went on to say that an ICT diploma (one of the first five diplomas) would be available from next September and that Universal home access was being looked at – this was announced at BETT.
Then came the questions and Jim’s answers:
- How will teachers be supported in costs of home Broadband? Basically none! A tax break would have been nice, especially when there’s bound to be some support for the less well off for universal home access.
- KS3 on-screen tests? Says not abandoned! Tell that to some schools who have already deleted the test!!
- Message to LAs about reduction of ICT support? Basically down to SIPs!
- ICT funding and schools not spending it? Guidance from Becta issued for schools to follow.
In all I felt the speech was uninspiring and the answers to questions and his delivery gave me the impression that Jim Knight isn’t fully clued up in what’s going on now or in the future in education!
IT Culture is Changing Children’s Brains
This was the first keynote from Dr Martin Westwell, Deputy Director, Institute for the Future of the Mind, Oxford University.
This was a very interesting presentation, if a little high-brow at times. Basically Martin said that today’s pupils think and learn in a different way to those in the past due to IT and the multimedia world they live in.
There was just too much talked about to note it all down and record it here. However, here’s a few things I picked up from it:
- A study of 48 undergraduates. Two groups, A & B. One group played the standard violent version of Doom (with weapons) whilst the other group played a non-violent version (without weapons). $100 at stake for each group to be the best. Afterwards in a game of Prisoner’s Dilemma those playing the violent game were 7 times more likely to exploit than those that played the non-violent game.
- Compare Medal of Honor to Tetris – games which demand high capacity for attention, develop attentional capacity (!)
- Brain Gym – no scientific basis that this makes any difference! VAK was also rubbished.
- A talking story for Year 2 children with “Read to me” and “Let me play” modes. Those who chose “Let me play” mode had worse recall of story.
- Deep brain stimulation – can control Parkinson’s Disease (a video of this was shown and it works!)
An excellent keynote and just what was needed after Jim Knight.
Making Space for Learning – Creating Physical and Virtual Environments in Schools of the Future
This was the evening keynote from Steve Moss, Strategic Director – ICT. Steve talked about BSF and the money for this:
£45,000,000,000 over 15 years
£4,500,000,000 for ICT
He talked about how the integration of physical & virtual spaces makes a 21st century learning environment and Learning Platforms were mentioned several times.
An interesting thought – in the future could a student be ‘present’ in school without attending? Could logging onto the Learning Platform from home and doing work count? A change in the law would be needed, not to mention a change in attitude. How would this work for some children when their parent(s) are at work during the day?
Steve felt that many VLEs today are not actually VLEs but VTEs – Virtual Teaching Environments – as they just replicate electronically what is already done in class (worksheets etc). To some extent I agree although schools who use forums, wikis, blogs etc are moving beyond this and are beginning to change the ‘T’ back into an ‘L’.
Wolverhampton’s ‘Virtual Workspace‘ VLE was shown. Basically Steve showed forum discussions – a student-mentor discussion and then a pupil-pupil discussion with their comments on a student’s poem. This is already happening in Bucks schools on Moodle.
Lots of nice pictures of innovative environments in schools were shown. The key message to me was that virtual spaces e.g. learning platforms should be considered as well as physical spaces.
Apart from the ministerial address it was a good start to the Naace Conference 2007.
Tags: Becta, Brain Gym, brains, broadband, BSF, conference, ICT funding, Jim Knight, KS2 on-screen tests, Learning Platform, Livermead House, Martin Westwell, Medal of Honor, Moodle, Naace, naace2007, Prisoners Dilemma, Tetris, Torquay, VAK, VLE